National stock exchange competition commission

When you are the country's largest stock exchange and a decision of the Competition Commission of India CCI goes against you. On 25 May, the CCI had issued a show-cause notice to the National Stock Exchange NSE , the country's premier bourse, for abusing its dominant position in the equity and equity derivatives market to lock out competition in the currency derivatives market, where it charges no fees.

The verdict follows a complaint from rival MCX, the Multi-Commodity Exchange, which alleged that the NSE was adopting predatory pricing strategies to kill off the competition. The NSE said no, and it was merely waiving fees as a form of introductory pricing. But while five of the seven members of the CCI found in favour of MCX, the other two didn't. This is why the NSE moved the Delhi High Court to get the dissent notes released. They are now out, and the NSE is banking on these two to bail itself out.

It hopes to use their arguments when it takes the fight to a higher court. The two dissenters, Geeta Gouri and Anurag Goel, did not find any abuse of monopoly by the NSE and, in fact, said that any meddling by the CCI would not help the consumer. According to Business Standard , the dissenters criticised the majority order for its "adversarial approach" which was not quite in the spirit of the competition law.

National Treasury

Firstpost looked at the numbers and the evidence and believes that the minority report makes more sense than the majority finding. One, there is no evidence of competition being affected by the NSE's zero pricing in currency derivatives.

Architecture of the New York Stock Exchange Building

Currently, the NSE, MCX and the United Stock Exchange USE are in keen competition, sharing the Rs 45, crore daily turnover three ways.

MCX is marginally ahead of the other two.

According to another report, MCX had an average daily turnover of Rs 16, crore, the NSE 15, crore and the USE Rs 13, crore since May Two, when "free" is bringing in huge turnover and benefiting consumers, where is the logic in forcing transaction fees onto all exchanges? As the dissenters pointed out, the late entry of the USE did not in any way affect its ability to garner volumes. Predatory pricing has, in fact, expanded the market.

This is what happened in telecoms and there is no reason why it should not happen with exchanges. Three, the majority verdict assumes that profits from one segment equity, in this case should not be allowed to subsidise operations in another currency derivatives. But this is exactly how the real world operates. Markets expand when companies use profits from one product segment to promote another till that one is ready to bear pricing. Four, the government itself does the same thing.

By underpricing fuel and cooking gas supplied by the public sector oil marketing companies, it has driven Reliance out of the market, thus reducing competition. But this is being lauded as a triumph of people-based policies. Five, MCX is the champ in commodity futures, thanks to its huge lead in metals and energy futures.

There is nothing to stop it from cross-subsidising currency derivatives using profits from here. So why are NSE and MCX scrapping like kids? The relationship was fine till MCX challenged NSE in commodities NCDEX and beat it to No 1. Once that happened, the NSE rightly assessed the threat from MCX as major and has been taking pre-emptive action in new segments like currency futures.

This is what one would expect a market leader to do. And from all accounts, the NSE has not exactly kayoed the MCX even in currency derivatives.

In fact, the real problem is that Sebi has not allowed MCX to get into equity. It is being muttered that Sebi blackballed MCX because it was a competitor to NSE Sebi's partiality to NSE apparently stemmed from its former chief CB Bhave's close links to the original boss of NSE, who made him head of the National Securities Depository Ltd, which manages the country's book-keeping for dematerialised shares and many other things.

But this can never be proven. The battle will end the day MCX gets the go ahead in equities. That's what Sebi and CCI should be focused on.

The Competition Commission would be better off focusing its efforts in other areas. The NSE-MCX fight is not the right area to flex its muscles.

Jun 06, Dec 20, Anil Kumble steps down: A timeline of the legendary cricketer's reign as India's head coach. Saudi king names son Mohammed bin Salman as crown prince: A few theories about why nephew was deposed. Travis Kalanick quits as Uber CEO: Here's a timeline of the company's troubles this year.

Nitish Kumar backs BJP presidential nominee Ram Nath Kovind, offers Opposition backing on everything but this. Pakistan beat India by runs. Zimbabwe beat Scotland by 6 wickets.

Topics | Investopedia

India beat Bangladesh by 9 wickets. Pakistan beat England by 8 wickets. Pakistan beat Sri Lanka by 3 wickets. West Indies beat Afghanistan by 4 wickets.

India beat South Africa by 8 wickets. South Africa in England, 3 T20I Series, India in West Indies, 5 ODI Series, Zimbabwe in Sri Lanka, 5 ODI Series, Ram Nath Kovind is BJP's ace in hole for Gujarat polls. ICC Champions Trophy PSL the catalyst behind Pakistan's title triumph against all odds.

Rain fails to dampen Yoga Day celebrations in Delhi, 15, gather at DDA parks, 10k at CP. Queen Elizabeth II to speak in Parliament on Wednesday to outline UK government's agenda.

Budding Indian artists all set to become nationwide sensations. Latest News Business News 5 reasons why Competition Commission is wrong on NSE. Competition commission of india Corporate rivalry Mcx Nse Use. When is a dissent note more important than a majority verdict? Also See Hyundai Motor gets Rs 87 cr competition panel penalty for unfair business practices Anti-profiteering rules: A timeline of the legendary cricketer's reign as India's head coach In Bastar, Maoists Make a Killing From Tendu Patta Trade International Yoga Day: From Great Wall of China to Burj Park, enthusiasts perform asanas Saudi king names son Mohammed bin Salman as crown prince: A few theories about why nephew was deposed 5 tips on managing investments in equity mutual funds in over-valued equity market Tubelight: Salman Khan cycling reminds us of Bollywood's unusual promotional gimmicks Travis Kalanick quits as Uber CEO: Here's a timeline of the company's troubles this year Nitish Kumar backs BJP presidential nominee Ram Nath Kovind, offers Opposition backing on everything but this.

South Africa in England, 3 T20I Series, ENG vs SA - Jun 21st, , Sections Front Page Politics Sports India World Business Life Entertainment Photos Videos. Plus New Delhi Mumbai Photos Videos FP Exclusives Video Room Weather. Others Sample Papers Online Business Technology News MTV India Online Shopping in India ICC Champions Trophy IPL E-Learning Franchise Opportunity.

Tools RSS Feeds Apps iOS Android. Firstpost - All Rights Reserved. Terms of use Privacy.